P10 vs. P12: LED Sign Comparison and Recommendations
When shopping for an LED sign, it’s easy to get caught up in technical jargon like P12mm, P10mm, or P6mm. Let’s simplify it: the “mm” refers to the distance between pixels. A smaller “mm” means a higher resolution, which delivers clearer images and text. For smaller signs, you’ll typically want a smaller pixel pitch to ensure the display looks sharp up close.
Remember: smaller is better 90% of the time. The remaining 10% depends on factors like brightness, which needs to be balanced for the environment. For outdoor advertising, a sign with a resolution of P6mm or smaller and brightness of 7,000 nits or greater is ideal.
Here’s the rule of thumb:
-
For larger signs viewed from far away: Brightness is the priority.
-
For smaller signs viewed up close: Resolution (pixel pitch) is more critical.
Take this request as an example. The table below outlines the provided specifications, followed by our recommendations to maximize the effectiveness of this project.
| Quantity | Model/Part | Product Description | Dimensions (L x H) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | MC-12mm-2.36x7.87-DS | 12mm Full Color LED Message Center - Double-Sided | 7.87’ x 2.36’ |
| 9 | MC-12mm-2.36x7.87-SS | 12mm Full Color LED Message Center - Single-Sided | 7.87’ x 2.36’ |
| 10 | MC-LightSens | Ambient Light Sensor - LED Message Center 049-1053 | - |
| 10 | MC-SMINF | LED Message Center Software Option - SMINFINITY | - |
| 10 | MC-Wired<325 | Wired Connection <325’ - CATSE Cable Sold Separately | - |
Our Recommendations
We believe these specifications are outdated and not the most cost-effective. Here’s what we propose:
Upgrade Resolution from 12mm to 10mm
| Feature | P10 (10mm) | P12 (12mm) |
|---|---|---|
| Pixel Pitch | 10mm | 12mm |
| Pixels per Module | 1,024 pixels | 729 pixels |
| Image Quality | Higher resolution; sharper and more detailed images | Lower resolution; suitable for basic text and graphics |
| Viewing Distance | Ideal for medium to close viewing distances | Better for longer viewing distances |
| Text Lines | Displays more lines of text with better clarity | Fewer text lines; less sharp |
| Video Playback | Smoother, more detailed video quality | Acceptable, but less detailed |
| Applications | Suitable for smaller signs or those requiring high detail | Best for larger signs viewed from far away |
| Cost | Slightly higher upfront cost due to increased resolution | Lower cost but less visually impactful |
| Future-Proofing | Upgradeable; components can be replaced for better resolution | Limited upgrade options |
| Environmental Impact | Components can be reused or refurbished for upgrades | Replacement often requires entirely new modules |
- Benefit: The 10mm model offers 1,024 pixels per module, compared to 729 pixels in 12mm modules.
-
Result: This provides a sharper, clearer sign with better image and video details, more lines of text, and improved readability.
-
Future-Proof Design
- The 10mm model uses our standard-sized modules, which are upgradeable. Instead of replacing the entire sign, you can upgrade components later, saving money and reducing environmental waste. Removed components can be refurbished and repurposed.
-
Warranty and Upgrade Program
- 15-Year Prorated Warranty: Coverage decreases by 6% annually up to 15 years. If a replacement part is unavailable, remaining credit can be used for trade-in credits toward an upgrade.
- Resolution Guarantee: Includes a 12-month resolution guarantee—if you're not satisfied, you can pay the difference to upgrade to a higher resolution. After upgrading, you'll receive an additional 90-day guarantee to decide if further upgrades are needed.
-
Standard Features
- Training included.
- CAT5 hookup and Wi-Fi extender for internet connectivity and remote access.
Discover Your Perfect LED Sign
Get instant pricing and customize your LED sign online today. Click the button below to explore your options and find the best solution for your needs!